
The Bundestag has hit pause once again: the Mietpreisbremse (“rent brake”) law, which was originally set to expire in 2025, has been given a second life. The conservatives (CDU/CSU) and the Social Democrats (SPD), with support from the Greens, have extended the rent control measures for another four years.
The law requires landlords in 3,800 designated “hot spots” – areas with a housing shortage – not to overcharge more than 10% above the local average rent. New builds and fully renovated properties are exempt from the regulation. In theory, the system seems clear: tenants can challenge inflated rents and even reclaim overpayments from recent years. But in practice, things turned out to be more complicated.
Data from the Ministry of Construction reveal a surprising picture: over ten years of rent control, asking rents in Germany’s 14 largest cities have increased by 50%. The reasons? A chronic housing shortage and weak supervision mechanisms.
The capital took things a step further in 2020 by introducing the radical Mietendeckel – a rent cap that froze prices below 2019 levels. However, the Constitutional Court quickly ruled the initiative unconstitutional, stating that housing policy falls under the jurisdiction of federal states, not individual cities. This precedent served as a warning to other “creative” regulators.
The Federal Minister of Justice, Stefanie Hubig (SPD) has announced new measures, including rent indexation and tighter oversight of furnished rentals. Conservatives, on the other hand, are focusing on accelerating construction, calling the extension of the Mietpreisbremse a “transitional tool.” However, experience shows that even 150,000 new apartments per year are not enough to meet the growing demand.
The central issue is still unresolved: will Germany manage to find a middle ground between tenant protection and economic practicality, or will the back-and-forth over rental policy carry on past 2029? What’s certain is that the struggle for affordable housing is far from finished.
Source: El Economista